Magpie
4.8(1,415 reviews)

New York City Mafia and Local Food Tour led by NYPD Guides

From$129
3h 5m
New York City, USA

Full description

Begins 5:15PM. Why join us? We LIVED this firsthand. Born & raised in Little Italy - or cops who worked the streets here - both active and retired/ NYPD Officers. Our “walk with stories” breaks the typical tour company mold of boring facts, repetitive "stops" & irrelevant dates replaced with personal life experiences. Walk the very streets where the mafia strolled with a real resident and meet other locals along the way. Plus food included is equivalent to a full 3 course dinner! Growing up witnessing some of New York’s infamous families and having consulted for TV and major films makes this a unique experience no other company can offer. Beginning at a famous Mafia "Red Sauce Joint" as seen in Soprano's and "Get Gotti" this experience winds through the East Village & Little Italy visiting notorious Mafia and Crime locations sharing personal true crime stories and eating amazing food from the neighborhood. Rated #1 "Things to do in New York" Recently featured in the Washington Post

Included / Excluded

  • Headsets ensure you don’t miss a detail
  • Spaghetti and Meatball, Eggplant Rollatini Parm, Sicilian cannoli.
  • Three food stops makes this a 3-course dinner. Stops are full portions not samples.
  • Insider Story from Retired NYPD guides & NYC Mafia expert.
  • Vegetarian options are available with advanced request.
  • Drinks are not included, but can be purchased on the day.
  • Gratuities are not included. We very much appreciate them!
  • Transportation on the day (if required).

Meeting point

Start Location

Unknown location

Cancellation policy

Free cancellation up to 1 days before the activity starts

For a full refund, cancel at least 24 hours before the scheduled departure time.

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Stroller Accessible
  • Service Animals Allowed
  • Easy Public Transport

Traveler reviews

4.8
1,415 reviews
5
1,302
4
56
3
26
2
19
1
12

This was the real deal

This was a fabulous trip! We were delighted and surprised at the knowledge, level of detail, and enthusiasm of our guide. We learned a lot and saw a lot. Highly recommended!

costaricadiverAug 13, 2026TRIPADVISOR

Jay the ‘Mafia Mob Storyteller’

Jay was exceptional!! Her knowledge and enthusiasm was second to none! The fact that she had 25 years in the force behind her certainly showed!! The tour, the food and all that Jay offered made this a ‘Mob enthusiast’ delight!! Would not hesitate to recommend!! Thank you Jay! What a fabulous evening we have both had! Chris and Vicky Spencer x

A4891VUvickisAug 13, 2026TRIPADVISOR

Great time on the tour with Jay!

Jay was an amazing guide, mixing historic and modern day gangster, crime and police dept stories and info. Highly recommend

O5836BJstevewAug 11, 2026TRIPADVISOR

Mafia tour with Jay

Jay was a great tour guide and very passionate about the city.

OnAir40618295141Aug 11, 2026TRIPADVISOR

Amazing Tour. Book Now!

Jay was amazing!!! Very knowledgeable and kept everyone engaged the entire time. If you visit New York, this is definitely a tour that you don’t want to miss. Highly recommend it!

447dawnadAug 10, 2026TRIPADVISOR
Book Now